St George Bank (SGB) Update

Submitted by Jim Thesiger on 20 May, 2008 - 16:43

St George Bank (SGB) has a price target of $34.00 from sharemarket analyst Macquarie Research Equities.

St George Bank (SGB) What could the other banks pay?

WBC looks well positioned with SGB Board support:

Given the SGB Board's support for its 1.31 for 1 bid (subject to no superior proposals being made), WBC appears to be well positioned. As a result, we believe a counter-bid would need to be at least 5-10% higher than WBC's proposal in order to win the SGB Board's support. This leads to two key questions.

(1) What is the EPS impact of a 30% & 35% premium counter-bid?:

WBC's bid implied a 29% premium to SGB's pre-bid price. If we assume similar integration synergies from counter-bidders at higher prices (30% & 35% premium) it would be: 1.0% and 1.9% dilutive for CBA dilution by FY11E. For NAB it appears "do-able" with 2.9% and 3.9% dilution. For ANZ it would be 4.0% and 5.1% dilutive by FY11E. As a result, ANZ appears out of the race given its PE discount.

(2) What synergies would need to be extracted to make it accretive?:

Alternatively a more "aggressive" integration may be required to make it accretive. We estimate WBC would need around 21% net synergies (as percentage of SGB's cost base, net of revenue attrition) to make its current bid accretive. For CBA to make a 30% premium counter-bid accretive it would need 28% net synergies (35% at 35% bid premium), NAB would need 41% net synergies (49% at 35% bid premium), while ANZ would need 49% net synergies (56% at 35% bid premium).

Neutral (from Buy) - Price Target $34 in line with bid terms (from $30)

Given its higher PE of 11.7x CY09E, CBA appears the most viable counter-bidder. NAB could counter-bid but would need to convince SGB's Board of a more aggressive integration or offer a cash alternative. Our price target moves in line with bid terms and, given limited upside, we downgrade our rating to Neutral.

Download our FREE App

Signup for Free
Don't miss out on your free share trading articles.

Free Risk Money Management Calculator for those who sign up!